IndustryWeek : Ruling Reverberates Through Open-Source Community
Home : Technology & Innovation : Ruling Reverberates Through Open-Source Community

Ruling Reverberates Through Open-Source Community

Novell wins in court, but SCO ready for next fight.

By Peter Alpern

April 9, 2010

A Salt Lake City jury sided with Novell in its long-running legal dispute against SCO Group’s claim it owned the copyright to the Unix operating system, a cousin to the popular open-source OS Linux.

The decision provides answers to some key arguments within the open source community. Throughout the lengthy trials and litigation, SCO Group demanded licensing fees from nearly 1,500 corporate Linux users on grounds that elements of Linux are based off Unix and violated SCO Group’s copyrights.

Novell did not make a similar claim and has repeatedly said it had no intention of suing anybody for copyright infringement.

“This decision is good news for Novell, for Linux, and for the open source community,” Novell wrote on its Web site.

Though some within the open source community initially said the trial is over, the issue of copyright infringement might drag on. SCO is reportedly weighing an appeal and is likely to continue its related lawsuit against IBM. SCO may drop the copyright infringement charges regarding Unix in the IBM case, but SCO has other claims related to contracts that it can assert against IBM.

Though SCO has not proven successful in many of its cases in recent years, many Linux users are still fearful that should SCO prevail, they would face costly legal action.

The battle dates back seven years ago when IBM was sued by SCO, which claimed it had violated SCO’s rights by contributing Unix code to Linux. A year later a similar charge was thrown at Novell, saying that it falsely claimed rights to Unix.

“Obviously, we’re disappointed in the jury’s decision,” said Stuart Singer, SCO’s lawyer. “We were confident in the case, but there’s some important claims remaining to be decided by a judge.”

Spotlight

How to Turn Leaders into 'Strategists'

By Jonathan Katz
New book by Harvard Business School professor explores why some executive strategies fail and others succeed.

Read Full Story
Also on IndustryWeek.com

New White Papers

More White Papers »

Poll
Is your business feeling the effects of the economic troubles in Europe?



Comment in the IW Forums.