What's the Root Cause of US Manufacturing's Underperformance?

June 9, 2014
Ten thought leaders debate the source of--and solutions to--US manufacturing's middling performance as the nation's economic growth engine.

What's the root cause of U.S. manufacturing's underperformance as the nation's growth engine? Suzanne Berger, an MIT professor of political scientist and co-chair of the recent MIT Production in the Innovation Economy project, says finance is the culprit.

Making her case in a recent cover story of the Boston Review, she contends:

"Since the 1980s, financial market pressures have driven companies to hive off activities that sustained manufacturing."

"To better understand the decline of American manufacturing, we need to go back well before the last decade to see how [these] changes in corporate structures made it more difficult to scale up innovation through production to market."

The change to corporate structure featured "the break-up of vertically integrated corporations and their recomposition into globally linked value chains of designers, researchers, manufacturers, and distributors..." Acknowledging that this change has had "enormous benefits," Berger assert also has "left big holes in the American industrial ecosystem."

I've summarized her 3,000 plus report in MIT Professor Fingers Finance as Cause of Manufacturing's Underperformance, though the original, How Finance Gutted Manufacturing, is worth the time to read. The issues troubling the nation's manufacturing sector are many, varied and complex--and are made moreso by how each reinforces the other.

Berger's contention, combined with the responses of ten other thought leaders, brings together many arguments regarding the importance of manufacturing to the nation's economy, as well as whether and/or how it could be strengthened.

Importantly, the perspective of the major manufacturing organizations and associations are missing. I'll be seeking other responses from these groups to continue and expand this important dialogue.

Sponsored Recommendations

2023 IW Web Survey Contest Rules

June 30, 2022
Online Contest Rules 1. Introduction: IndustryWeek ("Sponsor") is offering the Online Contest ("Contest"). NO PURCHASE NECESSARY. A PURCHASE DOES NOT IMPROVE YOUR CHANCE OF WINNING...

Accelerate mechanical design with automotive simulation software

March 10, 2023
In this free 30-day trial, learn how to accelerate mechanical design with automotive simulation software from Siemens.

A Quick Solumina MES Product Demo

Sept. 15, 2023
View this quick demo of iBase-t’s Solumina MES solution designed specifically for complex discrete manufacturers to help improve operational agility, standardize production processes...

Are you still fighting digital transformation?

April 19, 2023
Resistance to corporate digital transformation is still a reality even though the concept of simulation and digital technology has existed for decades, just not as a primary means...

Voice your opinion!

To join the conversation, and become an exclusive member of IndustryWeek, create an account today!