iron ore Copyright WorldSteel

Iron Ore's Price Surge Lacks Staying Power, Says McKinsey

“There’s little reason that iron ore is going to go above $45 to $50 per ton. If anything, there are probably more downside risks.”

Iron ore will probably snap back to $45 a metric ton as a nascent real-estate rebound in China won’t bolster construction demand in the world’s biggest user and supplies remain plentiful, according to McKinsey & Co.

The commodity will trade between $45 and $50 a ton this year, eroding a first-quarter rally to as high as $63.74 that was spurred by speculation demand growth will rise, Oliver Ramsbottom, a Tokyo-based partner, said in an interview. There’s no real improvement in Chinese steel consumption, said Ramsbottom, who’s covered commodities for almost two decades.

Iron ore’s 23% surge this quarter has surprised many forecasters who’d expected a fourth year of losses driven by sinking steel demand in China and rising low-cost supply. The rebound hasn’t swayed many skeptics, with banks including Goldman Sachs Group Inc. reiterating bearish forecasts. McKinsey’s view that iron-ore gains will probably prove transient came as one of China’s largest mills warned that the global steel industry’s crisis has become so severe that it’s comparable to a new “Ice Age.”

“There’s plenty of supply, there’s relatively weak downstream demand and sure, you get some uplift in price, but it’s not really that significant,” said Ramsbottom. “There’s little reason that iron ore is going to go above $45 to $50 per ton. If anything, there are probably more downside risks.”

Goldman’s Target

Ore with 62% content in Qingdao fell 0.8% to $53.75 a dry ton on Wednesday, dropping for a seventh day, according to Metal Bulletin Ltd. Prices, which posted a record one-day gain on March 7, have still posted the biggest quarterly advance since December 2012.

Goldman Sachs has a year-end target of $35 a ton, while Citigroup Inc. projects an average of $38 for 2016 and $35 for 2017 and 2018. Futures in Asia on Thursday signaled losses in the Metal Bulletin price, with the contract in Dalian dropping as much as 2 percent.

“With iron ore, we see it sitting where it is for a little while longer,” Tony Ottaviano, vice president strategy, development and planning at BHP Billiton Ltd., said at an industry event in Perth on Thursday, adding it made sense for the miner to maximize output. “When you see the Ebitda margins we make, I cannot understand why we wouldn’t operate these assets to their full value, maximize every bit of production we can.”

Home Prices Spur Rally

Iron ore’s first-quarter gain has come as data showed China’s home prices climbed in the most cities since March 2014 and steel prices rallied. Policy makers have signaled that they’re prepared to bolster the weakest economic growth in a quarter century. While the country started easing property curbs in 2014, the measures have helped to lift prices in the biggest centers, without yet easing a glut of unsold homes in smaller cities.

“You still have oversupply, certainly residential in the third- and fourth-tier cities,” said Ramsbottom, who lived in China for about 15 years. “If the government continues to say ‘OK, we’re not going to resort to increasing credit and allowing real-estate developers to start building again’,” then iron ore demand and prices will be hurt, he said.

Infrastructure and construction account for about half of China’s steel consumption, Bloomberg Intelligence estimates. As the country seeks to transition away from investment toward consumption-led growth, steel demand will contract 3% in 2016 after shrinking 5.4% last year, according to the China Iron & Steel Association.

The steel industry within China and overseas has entered into an Ice Age as mills contend with excess capacity and fierce competition, Angang Steel Co. said in an earnings statement on Wednesday. The country’s fourth-largest producer, which reported a drop in output, posted a net loss of 4.59 billion yuan (US$710 million) for 2015 compared with a profit a year earlier.

“There’s still a bit of uncertainty out there in terms of how the construction sector, the real-estate sector is going,” Ramsbottom said. “There’s no real, fundamental improvement for steel consumption growth in China.”

by Jasmine Ng

Hide comments

Comments

  • Allowed HTML tags: <em> <strong> <blockquote> <br> <p>

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
Publish