US Lawmakers Offer Cybersecurity Olive Branch

Concern over new cyber threats brings the stalled Cyber Intelligence and Sharing Protection Act back for a vote -- but this time with key concessions to privacy and civil liberties activists.

"Because the threat is so real I think everyone realizes we have to do everything we can to come together to pass a bill to protect our citizens," said Dutch Ruppersberger, ranking Democrat of the House Intelligence Committee

The Amendments

The amendments would also seek to clarify that Internet firms could only use data about threats for cybersecurity purposes, not for marketing or other commercial uses, and would give more oversight to privacy officers at federal agencies.

"Because the threat is so real I think everyone realizes we have to do everything we can to come together to pass a bill to protect our citizens," Ruppersberger said.

It was not immediately clear if the proposed changes would blunt criticism from the broad coalition of groups that unveiled plans last week to oppose CISPA.

Greg Nojeim of the Center for Democracy and Technology said the changes failed to address one key concern -- that information could be accessed by the top-secret National Security Agency, a branch of the military.

"This endangers civil liberties, undermines transparency and therefore public trust, and drew a veto threat from the White House last year," said Nojeim.

"While some of the amendments described today could be helpful, civilian control is the elephant in the room that CISPA co-sponsors refuse to address."

Michelle Richardson of the American Civil Liberties Union told a Reddit forum Monday that "a lot of politicians are under the mistaken belief that CISPA is a narrowly targeted bill."

"They are not aware of the sweeping implications of the bill -- empowering the military on our Internet, sharing personally identifying info, use for non-cyber purposes," she said.

President Barack Obama in February issued an executive order aimed at ramping up protection from cyberattacks, but said legislation is still needed.

US administration officials and lawmakers acknowledge that his order creates no new authority and that legislation is needed to better safeguard networks for key systems such as power grids, banks and air traffic control.

- Rob Lever, AFP

Copyright Agence France-Presse, 2013

Please or Register to post comments.

Subscribe to IW Newsletters

IW Marketplace - Buy a Link Now