Survey Shows Pensions Outperformed 401(k)s

Rates of return for professionally managed traditional pension plans outpaced those for employee-directed 401(k) plans in 2000 through 2002, the nation's most recent bear market, according to Watson Wyatt human resource consultants, Washington, D.C. This reversed the trend of the prior three years -- 1997 to 1999 -- when 401(k) plans achieved higher returns than traditional pension plans. The analysis found that defined benefit (DB) plans and employer-sponsored 401(k) plans both performed poorly in each of the three years from 2000 to 2002 due to the declining stock market. DB plans, however, outperformed 401(k) plans in all three years -- by 4.28 percentage points in 2000, 3.48 percentage points in 2001, and 3.83 percentage points in 2002. The year 2001 marked the first time both plans declined in the same year since the analysis was first conducted in 1990. "It's not surprising to see DB plans outperform defined contribution plans during bear markets, or at least in slumping markets that follow sustained, record-setting bull markets," says Sylvester Schieber, an economist and director of research and information at Watson Wyatt. "While 2000 through 2002 were bad investment years for everyone, DB plans didn't slip as far as 401(k) plans partly because the professionals who manage them have a fiduciary duty to diversify investments. 401(k) participants, meanwhile, may have over-invested in stocks and experienced significant losses when the market started falling in 2000." The Watson Wyatt analysis also found that, in each of the three years from 2000 to 2002, 401(k) plans sponsored by larger employers earned higher rates of return than smaller plans. This is consistent with the results of earlier analyses conducted through most of the 1990s.