Apple Targeted in China Pollution, Work Safety Report

'On Apple's supply chain, some workers were poisoned and disabled, neighborhoods and communities were polluted while there were severe infringement of workers' rights, interest and dignity," industry group says.

Chinese environmental groups on Jan. 20 singled out Apple for failing to tackle concerns over pollution and the health of workers at plants making parts for trendy gadgets such as its iPhone.

In a new report, the groups said the company ranked last in a survey of how 29 multinational technology companies respond to inquiries about pollution and workplace health hazards at factories in their supply chain in China.

The study reflects over a year's work by more than 30 Chinese environmental NGOs to pressure multinational companies into being more accountable for their impact on the country's environment.

"Apple has broken its promise on three aspects of supply-chain social responsibilities," said the report, the main author of which is the Institute of Public and Environmental Affairs, an independent Beijing-based organization.

"On Apple's supply chain, some workers were poisoned and disabled, neighborhoods and communities were polluted while there were severe infringement of workers' rights, interest and dignity," the report said.

It commends Hewlett-Packard, British telecoms operator BT, Alcatel-Lucent, Vodafone, Samsung, Toshiba, Sharp and Hitachi for taking some steps to change poor practices or step up supervision of manufacturing.

Apple was not the only company the report cited as failing to act or respond to concerns -- Nokia, LG, SingTel, Sony and Ericsson also fared poorly in the survey.

But the U.S. company was the worst, the groups said, for "dodging" questions from the public and requests from environmental groups for investigations.

"You should educate yourself. We do more than any other company on the planet," the report quoted Apple chief executive Steve Jobs as writing in response to an Internet user's question about its social responsibility record.

Apple's website says it is committed to ensuring the highest standards of responsibility and insists suppliers provide safe working conditions, treat workers with dignity and be environmentally responsible.

A Hong Kong-based spokeswoman with Apple denied the claims made in the report. "Apple has a vigorous auditing program that investigates suppliers and other parts of the business chain. We audit throughout... We actually have had an extensive auditing program since 2006," she said.

China's emphasis on economic growth over the past three decades has led to notoriously lax workplace safety as well as widespread industrial pollution. One incident the groups cited Apple for failing to address was the poisoning of 49 workers at Lianjian Technology, owned by Taiwan-based Wintek, which reportedly makes touchscreens for Apple. The case was widely publicized in Chinese media last year when the workers were hospitalized after being exposed to the chemical cleaning agent n-hexane. Workers claimed Apple did not respond to their complaints, the report said.

"Some workers recalled that representatives from Apple had visited the factory, but they never told them n-hexane, which was used to increase the output and rate of qualified products for Apple, was toxic and harmful".

In response to enquiries about the incident by various labor rights groups, Apple only insisted it "will never disclose any information about suppliers," according to the report.

Apple's highest-profile supplier in China is Taiwan-owned high-tech giant Foxconn, whose treatment of its workers was put in the spotlight by a spate of suicides that saw at least 13 mainland employees take their lives in 2010.

Copyright Agence France-Presse, 2011

Hide comments


  • Allowed HTML tags: <em> <strong> <blockquote> <br> <p>

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.