Tesla Motors
The new Tesla Semi

Daimler Throws Shade at Tesla E-Trucks Plan as Rivalry Heats Up

Feb. 21, 2018
Daimler has the most to lose if the Tesla Semi is what Elon Musk claims it is -- a total supply chain disruptor. But the German truckmaker is skeptical Tesla poses a serious threat.

Daimler AG cast doubt on Tesla Inc.’s plan to deliver electric heavy trucks next year, saying its more modest goal to start selling battery-powered big rigs by 2021 is more realistic.

The German manufacturer, best known for its luxury cars, is also the world’s biggest truckmaker, giving Daimler the most to lose should Tesla boss Elon Musk succeed in producing a semi truck with a 500-mile range for delivery starting in 2019.

If that happened, Daimler would have miscalculated to an unimaginable degree, head of trucks Martin Daum suggested to reporters at an event Wednesday in Stuttgart. He announced plans to start rolling out Mercedes-Benz electric trucks for trials this year, followed by mass production as of 2021. The driving range is smaller than Musk is targeting. Current battery technology doesn’t allow for faster timelines, Daum said.

"If Tesla really delivers on this promise, we’ll obviously buy two trucks -- one to take apart and one to test because if that happens, something has passed us by," Daum said. "But for now, the same laws of physics apply" in Germany and in California, where Tesla is based, he added.

The Mercedes-Benz electric Actros, starting with 10 vehicles, will deliver loads on city distribution routes with a maximum range of 200 kilometers (124 miles), Stuttgart-based Daimler said.

The Mercedes-Benz electric Actros is projected to have 25% of the range of the Tesla Semi.

German supermarket chain Edeka and parcel delivery service Hermes are among early testers who’ll receive vehicles in the next few weeks for a trial lasting around two years. Daimler will spend 500 million euros ($616 million) this year and next on its effort for electric and connected trucks, it said. Aside from Tesla, other manufacturers like Volvo AB are working on new technology to propel commercial vehicles. High costs and limited longevity of batteries have so far put trucks behind development timelines for cars.

The e-Actros as part of the pilot will feature two versions with total weights of 18 tons and 26 tons, Daimler said. They’ll take three to 11 hours to charge. Broad demand will need time to take hold, Daimler said.

"Trucks have to run for 1.5 million miles and then there’s a used-truck buyer too after that," said Daum. "We don’t know for sure how batteries for trucks will react after being in use for four to five years -- it’s very complex."

by Elisabeth Behrmann

About the Author


Licensed content from Bloomberg, copyright 2016.

Sponsored Recommendations

Voice your opinion!

To join the conversation, and become an exclusive member of IndustryWeek, create an account today!