Global Brands Face Growing Labor Militancy in Asia

Sept. 20, 2010
Workers are becoming more militant in their demands for a larger share of the region's economic success.

Global retailers fleeing China's rising labor costs now find themselves facing growing pressure for higher wages in countries from Bangladesh to Cambodia, Vietnam, India and Indonesia. The latest sign that workers are becoming more militant in their demands for a larger share of the region's economic success came in Cambodia last week, when tens of thousands of workers went on strike.

The mass protest rejecting a proposed 20% pay increase crippled Cambodia's export-orientated garment industry, which produces items for renowned brands including Gap, Benetton, Adidas and Puma.

The strike followed a deal between the government and industry that set the minimum wage for garment and footwear staff at $61 a month. Unions want a base salary of $93.

The Cambodian action came just weeks after Bangladesh's three million garment workers, who make Western clothes for the world's lowest industrial wages, spurned an 80% pay hike, attacking factories and burning cars. Tens of thousands of workers who sew clothes for brands such as H&M and Tesco went on the rampage over the 3,000 taka (US$43) monthly minimum wage offer then staged wildcat strikes protesting a four-month delay in implementation. "It is not a living wage," said Shahidul Islam Sabug of the Garment Workers Unity Forum, which wanted 5,000 taka a month to help workers cope with sharp increases in the cost of living, including near double-digit food inflation.

Earlier this month, Bangladesh said exports increased more than 25% year on year in July, with manufacturers linking the jump to a shift in orders from China to the low-cost South Asian country.

In China itself, workers scored major victories this year at companies such as Honda and Toyota and IT giant Foxconn, which were all forced to hike pay in the so-called "workshop of the world."

In an effort to ease worker concerns, most Chinese provinces, regions and municipalities have raised official minimum wages this year, with Shanghai atop the list, offering monthly pay of at least 1,120 yuan (US$166.)

"Costs are going up in places like China, so you are getting a move to Vietnam, Cambodia, Bangladesh and this is good for these countries," Robert Broadfoot of Political and Economic Risk Consultancy said.

And even if manufacturers are now facing wage pressures in the new manufacturing centers, they are on a different scale. "China is getting more expensive. To be sure, less developed countries are too, but the gap between per capita incomes in places like Bangladesh, Cambodia and Vietnam and those in China will continue to widen going forward," Broadfoot said.

"Wages of workers in these countries are unlikely to go up in absolute terms step for step with Chinas wages."

In Cambodia, union leaders called off the strike last week after the government stepped in and arranged talks with both manufacturers and unions for later this month. Cambodia's garment industry is a key source of foreign income for the country and employs about 345,000 workers. Social Affairs Minister It Samheng warned that further stoppages could "affect benefits for the workers, employers, and our nation that is facing the impact of the global financial crisis."

In Vietnam, where independent trade unions are banned and inflation is running at some 8.75% there have been 139 strikes in the first five months of 2010, according to the Vietnam Confederation of Labor.

The bulk of the protests concern low pay and poor conditions, with many of them hitting foreign-owned factories. Tens of thousands of workers at a Taiwanese-owned shoe factory in southern Vietnam went on strike in April.

In Indonesia, where three powerful trade unions represent the vast majority of the country's 3.4 million unionized workers, there is also mounting pressure to raise the minimum wage.

Garment factories in particular, including some that are foreign-owned, have been hit by strikes and disputes over long hours and low wages.

The minimum wage is not set in Jakarta and varies from district to district. In 2008 the highest minimum wage was $123 a month in Papua province and the lowest $60 in East Java, according to the manpower ministry. Tens of thousands of workers protested for minimum wage levels to be raised during May Day demonstrations in Jakarta this year, until riot police stepped in to quell the unrest.

India, which has a highly vocal workers' movement, has also seen recent disputes over pay and conditions at companies such as mobile handset manufacturer Nokia, car maker Hyundai and the technology and services group Bosch.

Copyright Agence France-Presse, 2010

Popular Sponsored Recommendations

Voice your opinion!

To join the conversation, and become an exclusive member of IndustryWeek, create an account today!