Industryweek 5645 Nokia Shareholders Approve Mobile Phone Sale Microsoft

Nokia Shareholders Approve Mobile Phone Sale to Microsoft

Nov. 19, 2013
"We are certain that if we had continued with the old strategy, we would have most likely put Nokia, its shareholders and its employees in serious difficulties," said Nokia board chairman and interim CEO Risto Siilasmaa.

HELSINKI – Nokia (IW 1000/109) shareholders voted overwhelmingly today in favor of selling the company's mobile business to Microsoft (IW 500/16) in an attempt to reinvent the once-proud Finnish telecom titan.

According to Nokia -- which will now become a telecom equipment and services company -- the deal was approved with 99.5% support from shareholders at an extraordinary meeting in Helsinki.

The "yes" vote was expected. Analysts judge the deal as positive for the ailing Finnish firm.

"It was expected that the decision of selling the mobile phone division would arouse strong emotions," Nokia board chairman and interim CEO Risto Siilasmaa said during the meeting. "We are certain that if we had continued with the old strategy, we would have most likely put Nokia, its shareholders and its employees in serious difficulties."

Nokia's share price has doubled since the plan was announced in early September, with Microsoft agreeing to pay 5.44 billion euros ($7.35 billion) for the loss-making company's mobile phone division.

'Excellent Deal'

"It's an excellent deal," said Pierre Ferragu, an analyst at broker Sanford Bernstein. "It's hard to imagine a better price for a division experiencing structural losses."

The sale of the assets, which include the Lumia smartphone trademark and technology, must take place in early 2014.

Once the world leader in mobile phones, Nokia lost its top place to South Korea's Samsung (IW 1000/14) in 2012.

Nokia remains number two in the overall mobile phone market with a 13.8% market share in the third quarter of the year, ahead of Apple (IW 500/4) with 6.7%. But Nokia is still far behind Samsung's 25.7% market share and ranks eighth in the fast-growing smartphone market, according to technology consultancy Gartner.

The deal spells the end of the once iconic Nokia branded mobile handsets, which have experienced a spectacular fall in sales since the arrival of Apple's touchscreen iPhone in 2007.

"For Nokia shareholders it's a good price because this business is loss-making and Nokia was too small to relaunch," said Eric Beaudet, an analyst at Natixis bank. "Nokia has good products but that's not enough. Their problem is their fixed costs are too high, which means they need 10% of the world smartphone market to be profitable. At the moment they have less than half that."

Today's vote presented an opportunity for shareholders to discuss the string of failures that brought the Finnish group to its knees.

Previous Partnership Failed

It's a long story, as detailed in former CEO Jorma Ollila's autobiography, which was published in October.

According to Olilla, Nokia was positioned well on the smartphone market at the time of the technology's infancy in 2004 and 2005. But when it took off in 2007 and 2008, the company's products were not up to par.

In 2011, a general manager headhunted from Microsoft, Stephen Elop, chose to partner with the American group, embracing its Windows operating system.

The move did not pay off. Nokia's profits fell precipitously under Elop, who resigned on the same day in September that the sale to Microsoft was announced.

Elop's role in Nokia's fall is still questioned in the company.

"How can you be sure that Mr Elop didn't leak confidential information to the buyers?" stakeholder Markus Magnfors asked during the meeting.

Nokia shareholders who voted for the sale hope for a return to profits and a new start in the fast-changing technology sector following a series of losses: 1.2 billion euros in 2011, 3.1 billion euros in 2012 and 590 million euros in the first nine months of 2013.

Microsoft will be left with the challenge of making the Lumia smartphone profitable, but with $80 billion (59 billion euros) in reserves to fall back on, it has some scope to invest.

Copyright Agence France-Presse, 2013

Sponsored Recommendations

Voice your opinion!

To join the conversation, and become an exclusive member of IndustryWeek, create an account today!