Court Likely To Decide Not One, But Three "Clean Air" Issues

Jan. 13, 2005
By John S. McClenahen Although yesterday's "clean air" cases before the U.S. Supreme Court were widely billed as a test of the EPA's powers to limit smog and particulate matter, actually three major issues are before the justices. One is the question ...
ByJohn S. McClenahen Although yesterday's "clean air" cases before the U.S. Supreme Court were widely billed as a test of the EPA's powers to limit smog and particulate matter, actually three major issues are before the justices. One is the question of whether the EPA can revise "clean air" standards, as it did with smog and particulates in 1997. But the court also has before it the question of whether EPA must factor the economic costs of cleanup into equation when setting industrial pollution-control standards. "For the last 30 years, the Clean Air Act consistently has been interpreted by EPA and Congress to prohibit the consideration of costs in setting health-based standards," notes Environmental Defense, a New York-based environment-protection group. The third question before the court is whether the Clean Air Act as interpreted by EPA is an unconstitutional delegation by Congress of its legislative authority. The answer to that question presumably would affect not only the EPA, but several other initialed federal regulatory agencies such as the FCC. Because of the importance of the issues, the Supreme Court is likely to issue its decision near the end of its current term, probably not before May, 2001, says William Brownell, a partner in the administrative law group and head of the environmental team at Hunton & Williams, a Washington-based law firm. The cases argued Nov. 7 are Browner v American Trucking Assns.(No. 99-1257) and American Trucking Assns. v Browner(No. 99-1426).

Popular Sponsored Recommendations

Digitally Transforming Data and Processes With Product Lifecycle Management

Oct. 29, 2023
Manufacturers face increasing challenges in product development as they strive to consistently deliver improved results. Discover how industry leaders are improving time-to-market...

Modern Edge Computing Accelerates Smart Manufacturing Initiatives for Discrete Manufacturers

Oct. 22, 2023
Discover how Edge Computing platforms are a requisite for discrete manufacturers to solve production challenges, accelerate digitalization, and establish a reliable infrastructure...

How Digital Twin Technology is Empowering Manufacturers

Sept. 27, 2023
This FAQ delves into why this technology offers business value and considerations toward implementation.

The Ultimate Ecommerce Excellence Checklist

Oct. 2, 2023
Scaling ecommerce operations is no easy task when your business is moving fast. Assess your current ecommerce maturity level and set optimization priorities with this practical...

Voice your opinion!

To join the conversation, and become an exclusive member of IndustryWeek, create an account today!