Where Should Lean Lead?

Dec. 15, 2010
I think it does a great disservice to manufacturers, large and small, to imply that they can pick and choose from some sort of lean buffet.
Many manufacturers who attempt to wrap their arms, and minds, around the concepts that have come to be known as "lean" make the mistake of trying to compartmentalize the philosophy. Unfortunately, Rick Bohan has done exactly the same thing in his article ["Small Manufacturers Need to be Agile, Not Lean," Nov. 2010].

While I fully agree that agility is a powerful byproduct of creating a lean environment and that the benefits he examines for small manufacturers are real and tangible, I strongly disagree with statements like this one: "It's just that the lean message' at least as it's been translated and communicated over the past several years, has little applicability to the circumstances of small manufacturers. Small manufacturers (and just about everybody else) have been sold on the idea that lean tools are primarily for cost cutting."

I've been learning and implementing lean for more than 15 years and have never been given the impression that lean tools "are primarily for cost cutting." Mr. Bohan misrepresents the traditional "lean message" as being one of "hoping for promised' cuts in payroll, improvements in efficiency and reduced costs elsewhere." Lean's message has always been one of responsiveness to customer needs, identification and elimination of non-value-added activities, and a passionate devotion to employee participation. Everything else is a byproduct, not a promise -- including the agility Mr. Bohan is trying to sell.

I think it does a great disservice to manufacturers, large and small, to imply that they can pick and choose from some sort of lean buffet.

Terry Durbin
Continuous Improvement Manager
Winegard Co.
Burlington, Iowa

Popular Sponsored Recommendations

3D Printing a More Efficient Factory Floor

Nov. 16, 2023
Today’s additive manufacturing platforms make it simple to print a wide range of high-performing industrial parts as soon as possible and right where you need them — unlocking...

Powering Up Productivity: The Transformative Power of AP Automation in Manufacturing

Oct. 25, 2023
Discover how AP Automation is revolutionizing the manufacturing industry, driving efficiency, cost savings, and security. In today's world, automation is the key to staying competitive...

Why DataOps may be the key to unlocking the full potential of digital transformation

Nov. 3, 2023
Read the 2023 market survey conducted by IndustryWeek

Digitally Transforming Data and Processes With Product Lifecycle Management

Oct. 29, 2023
Manufacturers face increasing challenges in product development as they strive to consistently deliver improved results. Discover how industry leaders are improving time-to-market...

Voice your opinion!

To join the conversation, and become an exclusive member of IndustryWeek, create an account today!