3 Questions That Saved Lego: The Importance of Leaders as Skeptics

If systematically challenging assumptions is so valuable, why don't leaders make it standard operating procedure?

Every day, growth leaders make decisions based on causal assumptions they have rarely, if ever, critically examined—much less challenged.

These decisions are consequential when they commit organizations and people to a set of difficult-to-reverse actions. “I’ve always been successful doing it this way” is what we often hear when people are asked why they didn’t question practices that turned out to be faulty or refused to try something new. Or they may insist that “this idea will never work” because of a failed attempt that embarrassed or frustrated them in the past.

People recognize the importance of questioning their assumptions when knowledgeable skeptics show that the ideas behind current practices are flawed or outdated—instead of simply digging in their heels.

If systematically challenging assumptions is so valuable, why don’t leaders make it a standard operating procedure? After decades of studying, teaching and advising business leaders, I’ve concluded that the fundamental reason is that many leaders don’t think or act scientifically. They are often reluctant to challenge their assumptions or to fund experiments that may prove them wrong. Despite decades of admonitions about the dangers of gut instinct, they continue to overrely on intuition and personal experience in decision-making.

People with a scientific mindset, by contrast, are knowledgeable skeptics who demand hard evidence. They are deeply committed to practicing the scientific method, which includes guesses, observation, testable hypotheses, experiments, and analysis.

'Is This Really True?'

When leaders are knowledgeably skeptical about the factors that enable their company’s success, it can lead to new insights. Jørgen Knudstorp did just that after he became CEO of Lego, in 2004. When he took charge, the company was on the ropes, suffering from depressed sales and stagnant growth. His predecessor, an experienced turnaround specialist, had launched a restructuring program to cut $140 million and laid off 10% of the company’s staff.

He had assumed that measures such as streamlining production; relocating design from small Billund, Denmark, to Milan, London and San Francisco; and launching online stores would fix Lego’s problems. But outsourcing production increased delivery times, global design centers increased product complexity and online stores frustrated traditional retailers. His predecessor’s assumptions were wrong: His actions drove Lego deeper into financial distress until Knudstorp was asked to take over.

Over the next decade, Knudstorp transformed Lego into a leader in the toy industry. Getting there required overhauling its business systems and constantly asking probing questions such as, “Is this really true?” and “Do we really believe in that?”

One of the things the management team re-examined was the company’s decision to outsource its operations to Flextronics. Management had assumed the move would streamline Lego’s supply chain, reducing costs, but it turned out that it led to longer lead times, higher purchasing expenses and shorter lifetimes for injection molds. Lego’s management recognized that bringing manufacturing back in-house would make the company more competitive.

By investing in cutting-edge injection-molding technology, Lego was able to provide users a better building experience that competitors couldn’t match. (The connecting forces of bricks had to be strong enough to hold them together but not so strong that they couldn’t be pulled apart by a small child. In addition, the new bricks had to be compatible with those manufactured decades ago. Only very tight molding tolerances could achieve that.)

Another assumption that Knudstorp challenged was the value of complexity. When he analyzed the company’s supply chain, product developers told him that the number of distinct shapes did not matter because the cost of an extra production mold was low. But nobody had considered the impact of additional components on design, manufacturing, forecasting and inventory management. You could be out of stock for a product because one of its 675 pieces was missing due to a wrong forecast—while still carrying excess inventory. Knudstorp also noticed that, between 1993 and 2004, the number of components had more than doubled because management had assumed that more components were necessary to grow the company.

Knudstorp, the knowledgeable skeptic, asked himself if this assumption was correct. He noticed that the number of components grew even when Lego’s sales stagnated or decreased. As a result, he reduced complexity by half and asked product developers to reuse more components across different construction toys. The move was opposed by five of seven manufacturing executives, who left the company because they disagreed.

A smaller number of components and higher reuse, it turned out, resulted in better forecasting, lower retail stockouts and more efficient manufacturing. Satisfied retailers made more shelf space available, going from an average of 9 linear feet in 2004 to 30 feet in 2009. Over the same period, retailer margins went from 19% to 30%, and inventory turns increased 150%.

Yet again, the skeptic’s intervention worked. When the company grew once more, Knudstorp made sure that any increases in complexity were closely monitored, justified, and controlled.

Detecting 'Essence'

Knudstorp’s skepticism extended to more fundamental questions about Lego, the company. Right after Knudstorp became CEO, Lego’s owner asked Knudstorp to meet a personal adviser once per quarter. During their meetings, they discussed three questions: What went wrong? Why does the company exist? And how do you know you’re getting it right?

Knudstorp had noticed that Lego’s managers attributed poor results to factors that were beyond their control; weak sales, for example, might be blamed on nice weather, which discouraged consumers from using indoor toys. For two meetings, he too tried to explain away Lego’s financial problems—the dollar had declined in relation to the euro, Disney had let them down and there were no more Harry Potter books to support branded products.

But eventually Knudstorp realized that it was, in fact, poor management that explained the company’s miserable state; he estimated that 80 to 90% of Lego’s problems were self-inflicted. The company had lost its way. The real problem was how the company’s erratic management reacted to outside changes.

Ultimately, a deep, probing process led to a rethinking of Lego’s unique identity—its essence—which guided management decisions.

“First of all,” Knudstorp said, “it’s a good idea that you have a unique purpose.” He compared the principle to being the only pizzeria in the 10,000-person village where Lego had its headquarters. “[Y]ou’re very competitive in the town, but when you move over to the next town, you lost all competitiveness. Being the only pizzeria in a small town is not a good strategy or a great purpose for competing more broadly, unless it’s a really good pizza, of course.” 

Second, he said, “essence needs to be something that’s quite rare, hard-to-imitate, and very important for obvious reasons.” 

And third, it must be something that’s highly relevant to society—in our case, to both children and parents. So, essence is something that solves a problem and is valuable enough for customers to be paying a good price for it. And if you can do all of those things, you’d better be good at creating that value and then extracting a margin from it—the value-capture piece—because the rareness and uniqueness also help you command a price that makes you a profitable producer.”

The process of detecting Lego’s “essence” involved listening to Lego’s community of fans, which led to the insight that the building instructions were more important than the company had realized because they allowed ordinary users to create extraordinary constructions. 

In response, Lego expanded the resources devoted to the creation of instructions, whose quality and style improved. (Today, many of these instructions are digital and 3D.) 

Listen and Be Open

Looking back, Knudstorp had learned to appreciate the importance of skepticism, humility and listening. A few years earlier, Lego had shipped 15,000 construction toys, and one critical component was missing. The toy was useless without the component, yet fewer than 5% of buyers complained.

“This illustrates an important lesson,” explained Knudstorp, “When you hear a complaint from somebody, I think it’s healthy to assume there are a lot more people who are unhappy.” In his opinion, leaders also had to listen to their teams, not just customers: “When a lot of us start a new managerial position, we think, ‘Oh, I got this job, so I must be brilliant,’ or ‘I deserve this.’ But you do not deserve it. You have to earn it by really listening and being open. And by the way, if you say to people that you’re not sure what to do, they want to help you. So put your ego away. In Lego we say, ‘Lego over ego.’”

Knudstorp’s skepticism launched transformational changes in how Lego operated. After going nearly bankrupt two decades ago, it became the most successful company in the toy industry. In 2024, the company reported revenue of about $10.3 billion and a net profit of about 19%, or DKK 13.8 billion ($1.9 billion). 

Reprinted by permission of Harvard Business Review Press. Adapted from THE SCIENTIFIC MINDSET: How Thinking Scientifically Drives Better Business Decisions by Stefan Thomke. Copyright 2026 Stefan Thomke. All rights reserved.

About the Author

Stefan Thomke

William Barlclay Harding Professor of Business Administration, Harvard Business School

Stefan Thomke is a leading authority on the management of innovation and the William Barclay Harding Professor of Business Administration at Harvard Business School. A management educator, speaker, and advisor to global leaders, his pioneering research has inspired organizations across industries to incorporate experimentation and scientific thinking into how they make decisions.

Stefan has published more than one hundred articles, cases, and notes, and is the author of four books: Experimentation Matters (2003), Managing Product and Service Development (2007), Experimentation Works (2020), and The Scientific Mindset (2026). Experimentation Works was recognized by Forbes as one of the top technology books of 2020, as a top business book of 2020 by Inc. and CEO magazines, and became a Top Shelf Pick by Strategy & Business.

Sign up for our eNewsletters
Get the latest news and updates

Voice Your Opinion!

To join the conversation, and become an exclusive member of IndustryWeek, create an account today!